Subscribe now

Mind

Free will: Can neuroscience reveal if your choices are yours to make?

Philosophers have wrestled with the question of whether we are truly free to decide on our actions for centuries. Now, insights from genetics, neuroscience and evolutionary biology are shedding fresh light on the issue

By Clare Wilson

27 September 2023

New Scientist Default Image

Jon Krause

SUPPOSE you approach a fruit bowl overflowing with apples, oranges and bananas, all perfectly ripe. On this occasion, you choose an orange. Or do you? Because although it may feel like you were free to pick an apple or a banana instead, many of those who contemplate such things insist that you aren’t at liberty to choose at all.

The same goes for all sorts of decisions we fret over, from the trivial to the consequential. If we could somehow rewind the universe, they say, you would behave in exactly the same way – because that is how your brain is made. Your sense of having free will is just an illusion.

The implications of such a claim are alarming because they force us to rethink many cherished assumptions. If our choices are somehow predetermined, there is no point agonising over moral dilemmas and less justification for punishing people for their crimes. This stuff matters. But can it really be true that none of us, as the poet William Ernest Henley put it in his stirring poem Invictus, is the captain of our soul?

While that question has long been the preserve of the physicists, philosophers and religious scholars, a growing number of biologists are now weighing in. Only this month, two leading neuroscientists have published books on the subject, both of which claim that a new understanding of the brain supports their case. So, with the debate having moved into new territory, can we finally figure out, once and for all, whether we have free will?

Determinism

The question has fascinated people since the time of the ancient Greeks, who…

Sign up to our weekly newsletter

Receive a weekly dose of discovery in your inbox! We'll also keep you up to date with New Scientist events and special offers.

Sign up

To continue reading, subscribe today with our introductory offers

View introductory offers

No commitment, cancel anytime*

Offer ends 28th October 2023.

*Cancel anytime within 14 days of payment to receive a refund on unserved issues.

Inclusive of applicable taxes (VAT)

or

Existing subscribers

Sign in to your account